brianjphillips

Friday, June 16, 2006

The image of a journalist


Does it matter how a journalist dresses and grooms him or herself? Has televsion media - and more recently and more visibly, the talk show circuit - changed that? The above Washington Post icon for the new PostGlobal feature made me think of the subject.

David Ignatius, at left, has more of what I consider the traditional journalist's image. Open collar. Hair a little mussed. Sunburnt - perhaps he just got off the plane from some foreign shore? You can imagine him sleeping on a cot, or in one of the bombed out Lebanese hotels Tom Friedman describes so well.

Fareed Zakaria, at right, looks a bit more suave. Dark suit. Hair gel. If he just returned from reporting overseas, it appears he was in air conditioning 95 percent of the time. And hey, is that lip gloss?

Granted, some of these differences are involuntary: I'm thinking age and hairline. But the style of dress and grooming are different.

Of course, one dresses according to one's beat. Ignatius might be covering a warzone, while Zakaria might be covering diplomatic meetings and interviewing CEOs about globalization. Perhaps that's why we see the contrasting appearances.

The challenge, though, is to have combat-zone cred while not looking too bombed-out yourself. Ignatius looks like he's been there, worn the flak jacket. He's dressed informally, but do viewers really want to hear about conflict from someone who looks like a corporate VP?

On the other hand, perhaps Zakaria is more keen to the interests of talk-show circuit. Tweed and earth tones can be charming and add authenticity, but they might not command the respect of the viewer.

But on the third hand, maybe it's all superficial and doesn't matter.

4 Comments:

  • I think, too, many don't realize (though I'm sure you do) that Zakaria's not really a journalist. He's a PhD in political science from Harvard (where he also taught for some time) and so what he might lack in flack-jacket cred he makes up for in big-thinker cred. Zakaria understands the big concepts of what's going on in the Middle East political scene better than 50 other reporters put together, whether they've worn flack jackets or not. I'd trust Zakaria over any of those Anderson Cooper wannabees any day.

    By Blogger Miguel Centellas, at 11:08 AM  

  • Excellent point that I should have mentioned! Zakaria doesn't come from a journalism background. Like Friedman (MA in Middle Eastern studies before starting reporting) but to a much greater extent, Zakaria has both theoretical and historical contexts in which he can place the day's events.

    But the informal/formal fashion divide exists in academia as well, though, of course. Tweed vs. double-breasted suit.

    And actually - digressing further from any "serious" subject - with all of U.S. society dressing down more in recent years, the fashion rift in academia is wider than ever, I believe. (My copy of "Academic Fashion in the 18th Century" is at home.) Some profs wear jeans, others do wear full suits.

    By Blogger bp, at 11:33 AM  

  • As for academic fashion. I tend to wear jeans & t-shirts (or whatever is weather-appropriate). I think I dress "nice", but I certainly don't care to "dress up." That's just me. I know others are different.

    In part, I believe students shoudl respect me for my abilities, not whether I "look" like a professor. Also, I move better around a classroom when I'm comfortable.

    In part, I just dislike the semi-dressed-up/down look that some people. I think one shouldn't wear a tie w/o a suit jacket, for example. So when I dress up, I like to go the whole 9 yards.

    Also, I'd mention that I think the dress code in academia is in part to identify where you stand IN academia. Go to conferences, and you'll notice a certain look to different types. My dissertation advisor once suggested that she can figure out exactly where a political theorist is located in the discipline's debates by how he/she dresses. So I always keep my eye out, and I've noticed patterns myself. At the very least, one can spot a structuralist (they LOVE brown/grey tweeds) from a mile away. ;-)

    By Blogger Miguel Centellas, at 11:29 AM  

  • That's hilarious about structuralists!

    By Blogger bp, at 7:24 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home